Mattina's Pizzeria

Located at 3744 Delaware Ave, Kenmore, Mattina's Pizzeria has garnered a reputation that speaks to both quality and care. With glowing reviews, this pizzeria strikes a chord with pizza lovers, particularly those who crave the Buffalo-style experience. Customers often rave about the crispness of the crust and the heavy, flavorful cheese that melts beautifully at the edges. Katie Nowadly Esq. praises the “non-sweet sauce” and perfectly cooked square pies, evoking nostalgic memories of her favorite local spots.

However, experiences can vary; while Kyle Matesic noted inconsistencies in quality—reporting a hastily assembled half-sheet pepperoni—the overall sentiment remains overwhelmingly positive. Christa J. and Laketa C. express sheer delight over the freshness and attention to detail, specifically highlighting the acclaimed Broccoli Chicken pizza and how hot and fresh the food arrives.

Whether it’s the “good good cheese” or the reliable service, Mattina's Pizzeria appears committed to creating an enjoyable dining experience. Customers appreciate the friendly staff, which adds to the welcoming atmosphere. With promises of both classic and creative pizza options, it's clear that Mattina's is becoming a go-to choice in the area. Ordering here could definitely be your next cheat day indulgence!